Acura TL Type S Automatic vs Manual

The Acura TL Type S is a high-performance luxury sedan that offers both automatic and manual transmission options. This comparison covers the key differences between the 5-speed automatic with Sequential SportShift and the 6-speed manual transmission variants, including performance characteristics, driving dynamics, fuel efficiency, and overall driving experience. Below are detailed sections comparing these two transmission options.

1. Transmission Overview 2. Performance Comparison 3. Driving Experience 4. Technical Specifications 5. Fuel Efficiency 6. Maintenance Considerations 7. Resale Value 8. Target Audience 9. Common Questions 10. Owner Reviews 11. Final Recommendation

Transmission Overview

The Acura TL Type S offers two distinct transmission options: 5-speed automatic with Sequential SportShift and 6-speed manual transmission.

Transmission Type	Description
5-Speed Automatic	With Sequential SportShift for manual-style shifting without clutch
6-Speed Manual	Traditional manual transmission with clutch pedal
Sequential SportShift	Allows manual gear selection in automatic transmission
Paddle Shifters	Available on automatic models for gear changes
Final Drive Ratio	Automatic: 4.438; Manual: 4.764
Gear Ratios	Different ratios optimized for each transmission type
Rev-Matching	Manual transmission features automatic rev-matching
Launch Control	Not available on either transmission
Shift Quality	Automatic: smooth; Manual: precise and engaging
Availability	Manual transmission less common and more sought after

Performance Comparison

Both transmissions deliver the same 3.5L V6 engine power but with different driving characteristics.

Acceleration: Manual transmission offers quicker 0-60 mph times by approximately 0.3 seconds
Quarter Mile: Manual completes quarter mile slightly faster due to better power delivery
Top Speed: Both transmissions achieve similar top speeds
Engine Braking: Manual provides superior engine braking control
Overtaking: Manual allows more precise gear selection for passing maneuvers

NOTE! Automatic transmission includes Sport mode for more aggressive shift patterns.

Driving Experience

The driving experience differs significantly between automatic and manual variants.

Manual Transmission: More engaging driving experience with full control over gear selection
Automatic Transmission: More convenient for daily driving and traffic conditions
Sequential SportShift: Provides manual-like control without clutch operation
Paddle Shifters: Allow quick gear changes while keeping hands on steering wheel
Clutch Feel: Manual transmission has well-weighted clutch with good engagement point

IMPORTANT! Manual transmission requires proper clutch operation to avoid premature wear.

Technical Specifications

Engine: 3.5L V6 (same for both transmissions)
Horsepower: 286 hp @ 6200 rpm
Torque: 256 lb-ft @ 5000 rpm
Transmission Options: 5-speed automatic or 6-speed manual
Drivetrain: Front-wheel drive
Curb Weight: Automatic: 3,646 lbs; Manual: 3,602 lbs
Redline: 6,800 rpm (both transmissions)
Limited Slip Differential: Standard on manual transmission models

Fuel Efficiency

Fuel economy varies between transmission types due to different gearing and efficiency.

EPA Estimates: City: Automatic 18 mpg, Manual 17 mpg; Highway: Automatic 26 mpg, Manual 25 mpg; Combined: Automatic 21 mpg, Manual 20 mpg.

Real-world driving may show different results depending on driving style. Automatic transmission generally provides slightly better fuel economy in mixed driving conditions due to optimized shift patterns and torque converter operation.

Maintenance Considerations

Different transmission types require different maintenance schedules and costs.

Automatic Transmission Fluid: Change every 30,000-60,000 miles
Manual Transmission Fluid: Change every 30,000 miles
Clutch Replacement: Manual transmission may require clutch replacement every 60,000-100,000 miles
Transmission Reliability: Both transmissions are generally reliable with proper maintenance
Repair Costs: Automatic transmission repairs typically more expensive

Tip: Regular fluid changes extend transmission life for both types.

Resale Value

Manual transmission models typically command higher resale values.

Rarity: Manual transmission TL Type S models are less common
Enthusiast Demand: Higher demand from driving enthusiasts
Collectibility: Manual models becoming more sought after as collectibles
Depreciation: Automatic models depreciate at a slightly higher rate
Market Trends: Manual transmission sports sedans appreciating in value

WARNING! Condition and maintenance history significantly impact resale value regardless of transmission type.

Target Audience

Different transmission types appeal to different buyer profiles.

Manual Transmission: Driving enthusiasts, collectors, those seeking engaging driving experience, weekend drivers. Automatic Transmission: Daily commuters, those in heavy traffic areas, luxury-focused buyers, convenience-oriented drivers.

Common Questions

Frequently asked questions about Acura TL Type S transmission choices.

Question	Answer
Which is faster?	Manual transmission is slightly quicker in acceleration
Is the manual difficult to drive?	No, the clutch is well-weighted and easy to use
Can I add paddle shifters to manual?	No, paddle shifters are only for automatic transmission
Which has better reliability?	Both are reliable; manual may have lower repair costs
Is manual transmission available with all options?	Yes, manual available with all trim features

Owner Reviews

Compilation of owner experiences with both transmission types.

Manual Owners: "More engaging drive," "Better connection to the car," "Worth the extra effort," "Feels more sporty and responsive." Automatic Owners: "Great for daily commuting," "SportShift is fun when wanted," "Smooth in traffic," "Best of both worlds."

Final Recommendation

Choosing between automatic and manual depends on driving preferences and usage.

Consideration	Manual Recommended For	Automatic Recommended For
Driving Engagement	Yes	No
Daily Commuting	Maybe	Yes
Resale Value	Yes	No
Ease of Use	No	Yes
Performance Driving	Yes	Maybe

Conclusion: Manual for enthusiasts, Automatic for convenience.

Test Drive: Always test drive both before deciding.