Acura TL Type S Manual vs Automatic

The Acura TL Type S is a high-performance luxury sedan that offers both manual and automatic transmission options. This guide compares the two transmission types, highlighting their features, performance characteristics, driving experience, fuel efficiency, maintenance requirements, and resale value. Below are key sections for detailed comparison and decision-making guidance.

1. Transmission Overview 2. Performance Comparison 3. Driving Experience 4. Fuel Efficiency 5. Maintenance & Reliability 6. Resale Value 7. Cost Analysis 8. Target Audience 9. Common Questions 10. Final Recommendations

Transmission Overview

Key transmission specifications: 6-speed manual transmission with short-throw shifter and 5-speed automatic transmission with Sequential SportShift paddle shifters.

Feature	Manual Transmission	Automatic Transmission
Gears	6-speed manual	5-speed automatic with SportShift
Shift Mechanism	Short-throw shifter	Paddle shifters on steering wheel
Drive Modes	N/A	Normal and Sport modes
Final Drive Ratio	4.39:1	4.43:1
Availability	Limited production	More widely available

Performance Comparison

Both transmissions deliver the same 3.5L V6 engine power but with different driving dynamics.

Acceleration: Manual transmission offers quicker 0-60 mph times (approximately 5.5 seconds).
Shift Speed: Automatic provides faster upshifts in Sport mode with paddle shifters.
Control: Manual allows complete driver control over gear selection and engine braking.
Launch: Manual transmission provides better launch control for spirited driving.

NOTE! Manual transmission models are approximately 50 lbs lighter than automatic versions.

Driving Experience

The driving experience differs significantly between transmission types.

Manual: Engaging, sporty feel with direct connection to the vehicle. Requires clutch operation and gear shifting.
Automatic: Convenient for daily driving and traffic. Sport mode with paddle shifters offers semi-manual control.
Comfort: Automatic is more relaxed for long commutes and city driving.
Sportiness: Manual provides more engaging driving experience for enthusiasts.

CAUTION! Manual transmission requires proper clutch operation to avoid premature wear.

Fuel Efficiency

Manual Transmission: 18 mpg city / 26 mpg highway
Automatic Transmission: 19 mpg city / 28 mpg highway
Real-World Difference: Automatic typically achieves 1-2 mpg better fuel economy
Factors: Driving style significantly impacts manual transmission fuel economy
Highway Advantage: Automatic transmission provides better highway fuel efficiency

Maintenance & Reliability

Both transmissions are reliable but have different maintenance requirements.

Manual: Clutch replacement typically needed every 60,000-100,000 miles. Transmission fluid changes every 30,000 miles. Lower complexity means potentially lower repair costs.

Automatic: Transmission fluid and filter changes recommended every 60,000 miles. More complex system with higher potential repair costs. SportShift system requires additional maintenance.

Resale Value

Manual transmission TL Type S models typically command higher resale values due to rarity and enthusiast demand.

Manual models: 10-15% higher resale value than automatic equivalents
Collector Appeal: Manual versions are more sought after by enthusiasts
Market Availability: Fewer manual models available, driving up prices
Condition Factor: Well-maintained manual models retain value exceptionally well

Tip: Manual transmission models are becoming increasingly rare and valuable.

Cost Analysis

Initial cost and long-term ownership expenses vary between transmission types.

Purchase Price: Manual models often priced similarly when new
Maintenance Costs: Manual typically lower maintenance costs over time
Repair Costs: Automatic transmission repairs can be significantly more expensive
Insurance: Similar insurance rates for both transmission types
Fuel Costs: Automatic slightly more fuel efficient, saving on fuel expenses
Resale Value: Manual holds value better, offsetting initial cost

WARNING! Automatic transmission repairs can cost $3,000+ if major components fail.

Target Audience

Each transmission appeals to different driver profiles and use cases.

Common Questions

Frequently asked questions about TL Type S transmission choices.

Question	Manual Answer	Automatic Answer
Which is faster?	Manual has slightly better acceleration	Automatic has faster shift times in Sport mode
Better for daily driving?	More engaging but requires more effort	More convenient, especially in traffic
Maintenance costs?	Lower overall, but clutch replacement needed	Higher potential repair costs
Resale value?	Higher due to rarity	Standard resale value
Learning curve?	Requires learning manual operation	Easy for all drivers

Final Recommendations

Choose manual for: Enthusiast driving, better resale value, engaging experience, lower long-term maintenance costs.

Choose automatic for: Daily commuting, traffic-heavy areas, convenience, slightly better fuel economy, easier operation.

Expert Advice: Test drive both transmissions before deciding. Consider your driving environment and preferences.

Support: For more information, visit Acura dealerships or contact Acura customer service.